You are here: Home » Blog » Will the iPhone 4 Replace Your Point and Shoot?
Advertisement

Will the iPhone 4 Replace Your Point and Shoot?

by Mike Panic on June 28, 2010 · 82 comments

Print Friendly

Photographer, computer network administrator and overall tech junkie are all adjectives that accurately describe me.  Apple fanboy, however, I am not.  While I am a Mac user and have owned no less then three iPods, I’ve never had the urge or need to get an iPhone or wait in long lines during the launch of them over the past three years.  This all changed for me, starting June 15th when pre-ordering was available for the iPhone 4.  

One of the main features that drew me in was the new 5mp camera with 5x digital zoom and 720p HD video.  For the photographer looking for something to carry around that isn’t your entire equipment bag, this is a great compromise

I’m happy to report that the camera functions beautifully.  Friday night I went to my local Velodrome to watch the races and do a first big shoot with the camera.  Admittetly, this is far from an ideal place to photograph as the races start when the sun is going down, harsh artificial lights and fast moving objects.  While not ideal, it is real life and what people will be trying to capture.

For the sake of this article, no photos have been edited in any way aside from resizing for the web,  and I took all photos in the horizontal, or landscape mode on the camera.

These photos required me to pan as I was shooting. I would prefocus and expose in the lower right corner of the touch screen to follow the lead racer and  shoot as I’d pan.  That explains the rear of the pack (left side of the 2nd photo) to show motion blur.  There are no manual functions on the iPhone camera so it does require some trial and error to nail a shot.

The photo below shows a lovely amount of blur and would look nice printed on stretch canvas.

By this point in the race I had no hope at all of panning fast enough to stop motion so I instead focused on the photojournalist and let the cyclists whizzing by show a lovely wall of motion blur.

Packing a somewhat impressive sounding 5x digital zoom, I was skeptical to say the least.  The iPhone camera is fairly wide angle, but zooming in with less than ideal situations really shows the limitations.  Again, these conditions are far from ideal, but they are a reality for us who shoot everywhere, all the time.

From the third turn of the track, this photo shows the start / stop on the track and the back side of the awards podium.

Zoomed in 5x on the iPhone 4, the JPG artifacts become very apparent at this point.:

Saturday I needed to run some errands and at one stop saw these brightly colored kayaks leaning against a store facade.  It was bright, but the haze and slightly overcast day meant no harsh shadows or reflections off the plastic.

Given these more ideal conditions, I’m happy with the color representation, even if it is a little saturated.  Using the iPhone to take this photo was also easy, the reflection off the glass face of the iPhone is barely noticeable when outside on bright days and the auto adjusting brightness of the screen helps to further increase visibility.

One of the best features of the iPhone camera system is the one touch spot meter function.  This is great, but it definitely isn’t perfect.  Below are two different photos, again neither edited, but clicking on the touch screen of the iPhone shows dramatically different exposures.

A hike Sunday afternoon gave me another opportunity to try out the exposure control on a very common and sometimes difficult shooting situations, horizons.  The day was humid and somewhat hazy, but the sky was still bright and our view from high atop a local mountain was several miles.  With the sky bright and the ground below dark, exposing properly is tricky for any camera without the aid of exposure compensation or lens filters.  Again, two photos below, neither edited, the same scene showing two different exposures based on where I touched.

My dog Bella came along for the hike and I was anxious to get some photos of her atop the climb.  She was hot and not in the mood to sit still, so this is the only shot of her facing the iPhone.  Sadly, the auto focus didn’t focus on her, rather the shrubs behind her to camera left.

The built-in flash included on the iPhone 4 was perhaps one of the most overlooked and sought after accessories that previous users were waiting for.  My Windows Mobile phone had a flash and, for what it’s worth, it was pretty good.  While I haven’t had as many opportunities yet to play with the flash in darker situations, take a look at the example below.  On the left is BBQ chicken legs on a grill, taken without the flash.  The iPhone adjusted the ISO to 1000 for the photo.  To the right I turned the flash on and the ISO dropped to 400. The results are pretty amazing.

Personally, I prefer how the right one looks, it has a warmer town and the flash almost creates a vignette look to it.

Out of the box, the iPhone’s camera function is pretty impressive, but there is still plenty or room for improvement.  What I’d like to see added by default, some of which was available on my Windows Mobile phone:

  • Exposure compensation
  • White balance
  • ISO selection
  • Manual controls

Again, my hopes are to eliminate the need to carry a point and shoot digital camera with me, and I think the iPhone falls a little short.  That said, I have a few photos that I’m very happy with that were taking in more idealistic conditions, perhaps those conditions were used when the sample photos were taken.

Accessing the flash and exposure controls are simply done by touching the screen, they work and respond fast.  The camera app itself loads fast, writes quickly to the internal memory and accessing archives and even taking photos in rapid succession seems to be without problem.

Accessing the photos on my Mac utilizing Image Capture gives me all the important EXIF data, and allows for easy transfer.  I’ve shot just over 150 photos total since Thursday night when I got it, along with a few movies.  I plan on exploring some of the photo editing, capture and emulation apps shortly because I feel they will give the camera functionality that perhaps was left on the cutting room floor in Cupertino.  Right now, I’m on the fence of it being a full time replacement fun camera, but with the help of some apps, the potential is there.

Bookmark and Share
Advertisements
  • http://twitter.com/photoletariats/status/17264628611 The Photoletariat

    Action and landscape photos with a cell phone? A weekend with the iPhone 4. http://bit.ly/9dk35i

  • http://twitter.com/mikepanic/status/17265497124 Mike Panic

    New Article is up! RT: @photoletariats: Action and landscape #photos with a cell phone? A weekend with the #iPhone4 http://bit.ly/9dk35i

  • http://twitter.com/brasonja/status/17268458478 Boris Rasonja

    Will the #iPhone 4 Replace Your Point and Shoot? | The Photoletariat http://ow.ly/24iiR

  • http://twitter.com/mikepanic/status/17284577537 Mike Panic

    @taptaptap I'd love to get a copy of Camera+ 1.1 to write a full review on @photoletariats -stock camera lacks a little http://bit.ly/9dk35i

  • http://twitter.com/petapixel/status/17302415003 Michael Zhang

    Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/petapixel/status/17302415003 Michael Zhang

    Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/bulldogpo/status/17302445730 Sami Suni

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/bulldogpo/status/17302445730 Sami Suni

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/fatherlyfilms/status/17302472998 Eric Bindman

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/fatherlyfilms/status/17302472998 Eric Bindman

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/genshin/status/17302477170 Junpei Hayakawa

    Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U /via @petapixel

  • http://twitter.com/karranfinlay/status/17302501246 Karran Finlay

    Yup, I think so! RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/coaten Chris Oaten

    Well, my point and shoot is a Canon G11. So, er… no. I don't think I'll replace it with an iPhone 4.

  • http://twitter.com/photonaturalist/status/17302678751 Steve Berardi

    Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U (via @petapixel)

  • http://twitter.com/striket/status/17302793553 Terry Choo

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • sglau

    no optical zoom? no decent flash? no replacement…

  • http://twitter.com/rodney_o/status/17302969685 rodney_o

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/espiegler/status/17303030899 espiegler

    really making me covet one. RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/panusd/status/17303096676 Panus D.

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/i_karu/status/17303115067 Karthik Rajashekaran

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/livelifelike/status/17303188799 Samana

    RT @PanusD: RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/dbryantphoto/status/17303278151 Don Bryant Thompson

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/ayrton360/status/17303282226 A Y R T O N 3 6 0

    RT @petapixel Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/leighrecrio/status/17303297379 Leigh Recrio

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/catcuervo/status/17303474143 Catalina Mtz. Cuervo

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/dougchand/status/17303479023 Douglas Chand

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • Harrison

    Even the original iPhone replaced mine. I had a Minolta Dimage X1 (I would still be using Minolta stuff if they hadn't given up the DSLR business, my Maxxum 7D is still a beast and takes excellent photos, but anyway..) but when it stopped focusing properly I never replaced it. It was my primary camera until I got my first DSLR, and at that point I viewed point-n-shoots as being something to carry in case you see something and need to forgo image quality for the possibility of starting a new internet meme. My iPhone fills the role quite nicely, not to mention I always have it on me.

  • Bluelily17

    neat, I was wondering how the camera on that holds up.

  • http://twitter.com/stephgail87/status/17303654351 Trixie Saquilon

    Of course not RT @leighrecrio: RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/sydweedon/status/17303720676 Syd Weedon

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/christinapotter/status/17303970951 Christina Potter

    Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U (via @petapixel)

  • http://twitter.com/andrewserff/status/17304033141 Andrew Serff

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/toddaburke/status/17304091514 Todd Burke

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/davidmielcarek/status/17304303179 DavidM

    replace "warmer town" with "warmer tone" under chicken shot ;) RT @petapixel: Will iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/griphine/status/17304560231 Tony Balt

    QT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/gfcelebration/status/17304944767 Inge/Gillian Harris

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/gma_ama/status/17305600947 numberone gma

    Already did. RT @petapixel Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/fotonomous/status/17306299300 Lydia Marcus

    Good question as i decide between new sony p&s or iphone 4 RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/mminiaci/status/17306412760 Mario Miniaci

    RT @ChristinaPotter Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://ow.ly/24wEf #iphone #apple

  • http://twitter.com/gatonaranjo/status/17306638465 Iván Ojeda

    “@petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U” / buen review sobre la cámara del iPhone 4

  • http://twitter.com/michaeljohn_888/status/17306783986 MICHAEL

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/greenkozi/status/17307368418 greenkozi

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/caparkinson/status/17308141889 Christian Parkinson

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/sailesh_panchal/status/17308476613 Sailesh Panchal

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/sagaru/status/17308593894 Sagar Uplanchiwar

    it already has !!! “@petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U”

  • http://twitter.com/clamdee/status/17308845637 Cameron Dixon

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/superfinefeline/status/17309066969 Karen W

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/matbee/status/17309162004 matbee

    Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U /via @petapixel

  • http://twitter.com/azzra/status/17309567915 azzra

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/whatthehelltwit/status/17309592461 WHAT THE HELL?

    RT @matbee: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U /via @petapixel

  • http://twitter.com/strickers66/status/17309837890 logan

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/mepphoto/status/17310750613 Paul Inskip

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U <- it's quicker than most point & shoots

  • http://twitter.com/jdyasdavidson/status/17312590913 James Dyas Davidson

    Will the iPhone 4 Replace Your Point and Shoot? – http://thephotoletariat.com/will-the-iphone-4-replace-your-point-and-shoot/

  • http://twitter.com/tracitoguchi/status/17313930078 Traci Toguchi

    Will iPhone 4 Replace Point & Shoot? http://bit.ly/b8BiKr cc @watarigoro @brianhancock

  • http://twitter.com/melmorsy/status/17314577463 Mohammed ElMorsy

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/niemand_jp/status/17315000526 niemand

    i4nのカメラって、こんなにえらいの?かんどーーー RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/l00karound/status/17315642683 ken mcmahon

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/alston12/status/17319038568 Ziyan Naseer

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/al904/status/17322429886 AL904

    Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U (via @petapixel)

  • http://twitter.com/reuters_oz_pix/status/17323185815 Tim Wimborne

    Will #iPhone 4 replace Point and Shoot cameras? – http://bit.ly/b8BiKr

  • http://www.cyclingcaptured.com Anthony S.

    I had my new iPhone 4 at the same velodrome on the same night as you. I got some wonderful photos and videos with the new and improved iPhone 4 camera. I truly am liking the camera a lot, especially coming from an iPhone 3G (I skipped the 3GS). The quality and sharpness of the photos are outstanding and the quality of the video is better than my pocket video camera (the Kodak Zi8). So, the iPhone 4 will not only be replacing my point and shoot, but my video camera as well. p.s.- I am the photojournalist depicted in the red shirt in your photo above. Small World!

  • http://twitter.com/kmtom/status/17324089311 Katelyn Thompson

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/thevideoreport/status/17324778577 Deborah Bonello

    talking of iphones and pros, see this http://bit.ly/b8BiKr (RT @photoletariats)

  • http://twitter.com/dar268/status/17325844719 Drew

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/holdstill/status/17328750836 carly

    It won't replace my G9, but it's a good start RT @petapixel Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/mikepanic Mike Panic

    Anthony – Small world! I would love to see some photos that you captured that night. Video from the velodrome is forthcoming!

  • http://twitter.com/mikepanic Mike Panic

    Like I said, I want(ed) a G11 but don't like the idea of carrying around a phone, car keys, wallet and camera, that's something in every pocket. Sure, the quality and control of a G11 is lacking in the iPhone, but overall I'm pleased with how it's working out so far.

  • http://twitter.com/cesylvester Carrie Sylvester

    Any comments on shutterlag? I haven't seen any reports on what its rated at.

  • http://twitter.com/mikepanic Mike Panic

    I'd say a best guess is 1/4-1/2 second, depending on the subject matter and if it's moving or not. I had more of an issue clicking the shutter button then anything. Shutter lag is no worse than any decent point & shoot camera.

  • http://twitter.com/bdoran/status/17341102698 Brian Doran

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/fotoview/status/17342155857 Wolfgang Lehner

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/dkutcher/status/17342200185 David Kutcher

    RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/firestained/status/17348954063 Justin Sherwin

    Will the iPhone 4 Replace Your Point and Shoot? – http://thephotoletariat.com/will-the-iphone-4-replace-your-point-and-shoot/

  • http://twitter.com/talenthouse/status/17396402914 talenthouse

    Will the iPhone 4 Replace Your Point and Shoot? Most are saying No! — http://ow.ly/24REh | via @photoletariats #photography

  • http://twitter.com/mikepanic/status/17417791265 Mike Panic

    @JohnMilleker I'd like to see an infographic on the # of enlargements actually made by consumers from digital cameras. http://bit.ly/9dk35i

  • http://twitter.com/baital/status/17418349396 baital

    NOW I want one : Will the iPhone 4 Replace Your Point and Shoot? – http://bit.ly/awSUd0

  • http://twitter.com/adoramapix/status/17957240458 AdoramaPix

    @mikepanic discusses whether the iPhone will replace your p&s camera: http://bit.ly/cK9gUB

  • http://twitter.com/mikepanic/status/17958389199 Mike Panic

    Thanks! RT: @AdoramaPix: @mikepanic discusses whether the iPhone will replace your p&s #camera: http://bit.ly/cK9gUB (via @photoletariats)

  • http://twitter.com/danscameracity/status/17958697379 Dan’s Camera City

    RT: @AdoramaPix @mikepanic will the iPhone will replace your p&s #camera http://bit.ly/cK9gUB -We teach iPhone classes! http://bit.ly/bLju1X

  • http://twitter.com/shempenny/status/18091043699 SherriPerryMitchell

    It will once I get my paws on one! ;-) RT @petapixel: Will the iPhone 4 replace your point and shoot? http://j.mp/bhS12U

  • http://twitter.com/mikepanic/status/19025124740 Mike Panic

    @thevelodrome thanks – you might also want to check out these photos of the madison a few weeks ago http://bit.ly/clAV97

  • http://twitter.com/dannisf/status/11109254878461952 Dannis

    @dincoocnid You can replace your DSLR with your iPhone4 http://ow.ly/3jXoI

Previous post:

Next post:

Advertisement