You are here: Home » Blog » Guest Blog: Poor Editing is Ruining Concert Photography
Advertisement

Guest Blog: Poor Editing is Ruining Concert Photography

by Jacob Blickenstaff on June 29, 2010 · 72 comments

Print Friendly

Danny Kroha, Detroit 2010 ©Jacob Blickenstaff

I can’t hold my tongue on this subject anymore: there are too many competent, talented and creative photographers shooting themselves in the foot by neglecting to edit their work.  There are also many developing photographers who are not progressing because they can’t tell their good work from their bad.

The Current State of Things:

Music photography and how it is being used on many websites and blogs runs against good judgement and taste. Music websites and blogs have an unlimited appetite for content, and it doesn’t really seem to matter what the quality of that content is. I’m not sure why this happens, but probably in the race for clicks and S.E.O. rankings, images are being exploited to serve as Googlebot fodder and snarky comment bait.  A photograph’s power to beautifully and bluntly get to the heart of the matter is being lost and abused.

A prominent music blog that I’ve shot for is a regular offender, though I see these problems all over the place.  A recent post covering a 45-minute afternoon outdoor show featured a whopping 73 photos. 25 of those were dedicated solely to the children in the audience doing cute children things.  And what’s more,  the photos were processed digitally in at least 4 different ways: some were ‘as shot’, some were converted to black & white, some had a cross-process filter, and some had heavy handed saturation and contrast boost.  These numbers are the actual count, I’m not hyperbolizing. What did all these photos say about the music?  Absolutely nothing.

If the photographer had run the 5 best shots, in a consistent style, that communicated all aspects of the event, I would have learned something about the artist, the performance and also the photographer. All I learned from this jumbled mess was that the weather was sunny, kids are annoying and that the photographer might need treatment for A.D.H.D.

Why Editing is More Important than Shooting:

Everybody makes awful photos.   Editing is just as important, if not more important than the process of shooting.  When you shoot, you should take risks, remain open to new experiences, and try new techniques.  And when you edit, you must look at what worked and what failed, eliminate redundant photos and adjust your approach for next time.  Only by consciously recognizing both your successes and your failures can you grow as a photographer.  It’s always hard to toss out 95% of your work, but you have to cut out the junk so that the rest can shine.

Photography, in both shooting and editing is about intent and the relationship between you and the subject. When you show 4 different styles within a set of images, you are telling your audience that you had no idea what your intent was.  Converting a lesser photo to black and white is not editing, it’s a cop-out.

Stop Being Your Own Worst Enemy:

Quit showing the world your bad photos. Period.  It makes you look bad. If it’s the policy of the website to expect 50+ images of one event, stand up for your right to only show work you are proud of, especially if you aren’t getting paid.  If you deliver 15 stunning images, only an idiot would ask, ‘Hey, where’s the rest?’. If the work isn’t good you’re hurting your professional image more than you are helping it.

Why, as a photographer, would you want crummy photographs representing your name and identity?  For every beautiful photo you have in a series, one clunker detracts enormously from it. It tells the educated viewer (such as the record label, band or magazine who might hire you one day) that you that have poor judgement. You need to be a ruthless editor for your own sake.

Truth and beauty is only found in the best 1% of what we do.  Get out your scalpels and start cutting.

Guest Blogger Jacob Blickenstaff is a music photographer who blogs and tweets. His last post was Everything You Know about Concert Photography is Wrong.

Bookmark and Share
Advertisements
  • http://twitter.com/photoletariats/status/17361761672 The Photoletariat

    Poor editing is ruining concert photography http://bit.ly/aTiX9Y

  • http://twitter.com/deseraestage/status/17361826280 Dese’Rae Stage

    another home run by @jblickenstaff. RT @photoletariats: Poor editing is ruining concert photography http://bit.ly/aTiX9Y

  • http://twitter.com/simonridgway/status/17362149960 Simon Ridgway

    RT @photoletariats: Poor editing is ruining concert photography http://bit.ly/aTiX9Y <– bang on. And doesn't just apply to concerts.

  • http://www.rossahall.com/ Ross Hall

    Couldn't agree more with this one. It does seem the urge for “quantity over quality” is ruining some sites and pulling standards down. Is this image any more interesting than the next one with the left arm three quarters of a centimetre further down? Who cares – publish it anyways!

    I'm setting myself a target – one set, one shot. Find the stand-out one, go with it, screw the others!

    We'll see how that goes …!

  • http://twitter.com/extrajection/status/17363084361 David Hawkins-Weeks

    Good article on why poor editing is ruining concert #photography by Jacob Blickenstaff (@photoletariats) http://j.mp/aqVa2C

  • http://twitter.com/jblickenstaff/status/17363735032 Jacob Blickenstaff

    My latest post (rant) on The Photoletariat: How poor editing is harming your career and concert photography http://bit.ly/bQoBx6

  • http://twitter.com/3313photo/status/17363736303 33 1/3 Photo + Promo

    My latest post (rant) on The Photoletariat: How poor editing is harming your career and concert photography http://bit.ly/bQoBx6

  • http://twitter.com/hernancastillox/status/17364071697 Hernan Castillo

    RT @3313photo: My latest post (rant) on The Photoletariat: How poor editing is harming your career and concert photography http://bit.ly/bQoBx6

  • http://twitter.com/lpvgallery/status/17364270003 La Pura Vida Gallery

    "Poor Editing is Ruining Concert Photography" http://bit.ly/bharjM or why you might need the LPV editing service http://bit.ly/amaADO

  • http://twitter.com/jblickenstaff/status/17365105502 Jacob Blickenstaff

    RT @deseraestage: another home run by @jblickenstaff. RT @photoletariats: Poor editing is ruining concert photography http://bit.ly/aTiX9Y

  • http://twitter.com/lakayembahphoto/status/17365256189 LaKaye Mbah

    RT @photoletariats: Poor editing is ruining concert photography http://bit.ly/aTiX9Y

  • http://twitter.com/bonjourkat/status/17365397897 kat i.

    RT @jblickenstaff: My latest post (rant): How poor editing is harming your career and concert photography http://bit.ly/bQoBx6

  • http://twitter.com/photoletariats/status/17365449384 The Photoletariat

    home run by @jblickenstaff. RT @photoletariats: Poor editing is ruining concert photography http://bit.ly/aTiX9Y (via @deseraestage)

  • http://twitter.com/backstageat/status/17367991805 Kevin Tachman

    RT @jblickenstaff: My latest post (rant) on The Photoletariat: How poor editing is harming your career and concert photography http://bit.ly/bQoBx6

  • http://blogs.sas.com/anz Evan Stubbs

    Yeah, I know what you mean. One of the things I've struggled with the most is fighting against the temptation to include too many photos; the instinctual reaction is to believe that delivery has something to do with volume. So, if they're paying X, they're getting more value if they get more photos …

    The reality is that they're paying for quality, not quantity. There's a certain minimum quantity that still needs to be delivered, but beyond that, it's more about providing a small enough set of photos that they can be comfortably browsed through while still capturing the emotion of the event. Most people don't want to look through fifty or a hundred photos – better to provide a smaller set that's interesting and leaves them wanting more.

  • http://twitter.com/sesh/status/17383686620 Brenton Cleeland

    The importance, and lack of, editing in music photography – http://bit.ly/bQoBx6

  • http://twitter.com/kathrynyu/status/17385571352 Kathryn Yu

    RT @jblickenstaff: My latest post (rant) on The Photoletariat: How poor editing is harming your career and concert photography http://bit.ly/bQoBx6

  • http://twitter.com/zeefred/status/17386741367 zefred

    Guest Blog: Poor Editing is Ruining Concert Photography – The … http://bit.ly/99HXIn

  • http://twitter.com/roccokasby/status/17389183096 Roger Kisby

    RT @jblickenstaff: My latest post (rant) on The Photoletariat: How poor editing is harming your career and concert photography http://bit.ly/bQoBx6

  • http://twitter.com/martkleppe/status/17397051848 Martijn Kleppe

    Meer over concertfotografie: 'Poor Editing is Ruining Concert Photography' @photoletariats http://bit.ly/bQoBx6 #dutchdoc

  • http://twitter.com/wateenwereld/status/17397114008 Esther van Berk

    RT @MartKleppe: Meer over concertfotografie: 'Poor Editing is Ruining Concert Photography' @photoletariats http://bit.ly/bQoBx6 #dutchdoc

  • http://twitter.com/liveon35mm/status/17400965648 liveon35mm

    Nice post, nice tip, nice blog and best name ever. What do you want more when you have The Photoletariat? http://fb.me/Cj71b7jF

  • http://twitter.com/danielmking/status/17401182679 Daniel King

    RT @liveon35mm: Nice post, nice tip, nice blog and best name ever. What do you want more when you have The Photoletariat? http://fb.me/Cj71b7jF

  • http://twitter.com/kgustafson/status/17408654791 Kyle Gustafson

    Preach on. RT @jblickenstaff: My latest post: How poor editing is harming your career and concert photography http://bit.ly/bQoBx6

  • http://twitter.com/amazingagain/status/17408884604 Amy W.

    RT @kgustafson: Preach on. RT @jblickenstaff: My latest post: How poor editing is harming your career and concert photography http://bit.ly/bQoBx6

  • http://twitter.com/matteisman/status/17415213061 Matt Eisman

    Spot on. RT @jblickenstaff: My latest post (rant) on The Photoletariat: How poor editing is harming your career http://bit.ly/bQoBx6

  • http://twitter.com/ksphotohound/status/17416968134 John Peterson

    Guest Blog: Poor Editing is Ruining Concert Photography – The … http://bit.ly/af69T1

  • http://twitter.com/barthdoesthings/status/17422295833 Chris Barth

    On the necessity of music photogs self-editing. Same principles apply to bloggers in general. http://bit.ly/cQfwdQ (saw it via @matteisman)

  • http://twitter.com/pixfeedla/status/17449459749 pix

    "Poor editing is Ruining Concert Photography" http://ow.ly/2562G

  • http://twitter.com/emayoh/status/17450357762 Mick Orlosky

    RT @PIXFeedLA: "Poor editing is Ruining Concert Photography" http://ow.ly/2562G

  • http://twitter.com/cardassianv0le/status/17452605487 Amber Gregory

    Guest Blog: Poor Editing is Ruining Concert Photography -http://bit.ly/bqG91s

  • Sweetgemm

    what makes you the authority? that's just your aesthetic. why can't the rules change as mediums and expression and access and distribution changes? various outlets using the same type of media have always differentiated themselves by standards. the internet is no different. one blog can be amateur hour, and another can uphold certain standards. like magazines, newspapers, etc did and still do. eg national geographic vs. i don't know… some weekly tourist travel mag.

  • http://twitter.com/jblickenstaff/status/17500815023 Jacob Blickenstaff

    RT @kgustafson: Preach on. RT @jblickenstaff: My latest post: How poor editing is harming your career and concert photography http://bit.ly/bQoBx6

  • http://twitter.com/jblickenstaff/status/17500823137 Jacob Blickenstaff

    RT @matteisman: Spot on. RT @jblickenstaff: My latest post (rant) on The Photoletariat: How poor editing is harming your career http://bit.ly/bQoBx6

  • http://twitter.com/wohei/status/17501386027 Wolfgang Heisel

    Recht hat er. Ich gelobe Besserung meine Seite betreffend: @jblickenstaff Poor Editing is Ruining Concert Photography – http://bit.ly/bQoBx6

  • http://twitter.com/gigphotog/status/17507173021 Kunal Kakodkar

    Wisdom from @jblickenstaff – Poor Editing is Ruining Concert Photography – http://bit.ly/bQoBx6

  • http://twitter.com/shivahuja/status/17507412311 Shiv Ahuja

    RT @gigphotog: Wisdom from @jblickenstaff – Poor Editing is Ruining Concert Photography – http://bit.ly/bQoBx6

  • http://twitter.com/swarnabhghosh/status/17508834139 Swarnabh Ghosh

    RT @shivahuja: RT @gigphotog: Wisdom from @jblickenstaff – Poor Editing is Ruining Concert Photography – http://bit.ly/bQoBx6

  • http://twitter.com/sniper_photo/status/17539707054 Ryan Armbrust

    Poor Editing is Ruining Concert Photography http://regator.com/?u=40vs2k

  • http://twitter.com/sydweedon/status/17540204003 Syd Weedon

    RT @Sniper_Photo: Poor Editing is Ruining Concert Photography http://regator.com/?u=40vs2k

  • Jacob

    not an authority, just informed. A bad photograph is a bad photograph where ever it may be found. Media and outlets with low standards are equally to blame.

  • http://twitter.com/videocameratips/status/17685068050 Ivan Walsh

    Why Poor Editing is Ruining Concert Photography http://bit.ly/99HXIn

  • http://twitter.com/caztheturtle/status/17694813601 Carole Whitehead

    RT @sesh: The importance, and lack of, editing in music photography – http://bit.ly/bQoBx6

  • Walter

    I agree with this article completely. Take a look at Alternative Press's coverage of the 2009 Vans Warped Tour. Alternative Press sent 3-5 photographers to every single date and asked them all to send in their best 20 pictures. What the AP do with them? They posted every single one on their website. How many dates were there for that tour last summer? Multiply that by 60-100 pictures per date? Does that quantity of imagery add any value at all? Now consider another magazine like Rolling Stone who may send one photographer to one of the early dates of a major tour and publish 5-10 images total. Which publication's imagery is more respected?

  • Rollingstoner

    The problem with Rolling Stone is that they have an unending supply of hungry photographers trying to get in the door. All the great portrait shoots go to Seliger, Yang (who deserve it) and Theo Wenner (who doesn't). Because live photographers are so dispensable, the editors there sometimes use us for one spec assignment then throw you in the bin.

  • http://twitter.com/digigrl2/status/17843985630 Cynthia Nichols

    RT @3313photo: My latest post (rant) on The Photoletariat: How poor editing is harming your career and concert photography http://bit.ly/bQoBx6

  • JAY

    ABSOLUTELY RIGHT ON! THE BAD EDITING JUST SHOWS HOW MEDIOCRE CONCERT PHOTOGRAPHY HAS BECOME! MOST OF THE SHOOTERS SENDING TO WEBSITES CANT TAKE A BRILLIANT PHOTO TO SAVE THEIR LIVES, SO SHOWING 80 BAD ONES DOES NOT HELP.
    TAKE CHANCES, AND SHOW THE 5 KILLER SHOTS! AND I AM JUST AS GUILTY FOR OFTEN TIMES SHOWING TO MUCH WORK…AND AUTOFOCUS, AUTO EXPOSURE, AND HOLDING THE CAMERA IN THE AIR AND NOT LOOKING THRU THE VIEWFINDER IS ONLY AUTO-CREATIVITY, NOT GREAT IMAGE MAKING.

  • http://twitter.com/vanguardphotous/status/17973249527 Vanguard Photo US

    Jacob Blickenstaff talks photo editing and concert photography on the Photoletariat:… http://fb.me/Cl8lu5o3

  • http://twitter.com/3313photo/status/18240252415 33 1/3 Photo + Promo

    RT @VanguardPhotoUS: Jacob Blickenstaff talks photo editing and concert photography on the Photoletariat:… http://fb.me/Cl8lu5o3

  • http://twitter.com/jblickenstaff/status/18240286987 Jacob Blickenstaff

    RT @VanguardPhotoUS: Jacob Blickenstaff talks photo editing and concert photography on the Photoletariat:… http://fb.me/Cl8lu5o3

  • http://twitter.com/cruz9725/status/18241129659 Jorge Cruz

    RT @VanguardPhotoUS: Jacob Blickenstaff talks photo editing and concert photography on the Photoletariat:… http://fb.me/Cl8lu5o3

  • http://twitter.com/bebopdesigner/status/18241320291 Pablo Contreras

    RT @VanguardPhotoUS: Jacob Blickenstaff talks photo editing and concert photography on the Photoletariat:… http://fb.me/Cl8lu5o3

  • http://twitter.com/filipowich/status/18242512790 Matthew Filipowich

    RT @VanguardPhotoUS: Jacob Blickenstaff talks photo editing and concert photography on the Photoletariat:… http://fb.me/Cl8lu5o3

  • http://thephotoletariat.com/evolve-your-music-photography-get-out-of-the-pit-and-go-backstage/ Out of the Pit and Backstage: Evolving Your Music Photography – The Photoletariat

    [...] Having concisely edited, well presented work speaks of your vision, talents and ability to follow through on a project. [...]

  • http://twitter.com/jxe520/status/18738078023 Ed

    Reading: Poor Editing is Ruining Concert Photography – http://tinyurl.com/2b4tbzn. I know editing is my weak point & I show too many photos.

  • Yolotengo

    why not edit the shot at the top of the page then? 3 nearly identical shots?? why?

  • http://twitter.com/escandon09/status/19792852307 Jesus Escandon

    Guest Blog: Poor Editing is Ruining Concert Photography – The Photoletariat http://su.pr/2m19GY

  • Jacob

    That is the point exactly, was trying to give an illustration.

  • Unknown Frames

    i disagree with black and white being a cop out, Kevin Cummins shot mainly in b&w. Editing more important than shooting? WRONG! Why even shoot if you depend on editing? Make your shots count from the very start. How about framing and properly exposing from your camera? Why even touch photoshop? On the concert photography deal, yes i agree.

  • codename

    http://onlinephotoedit.webs.com/
    online photo editors list

  • a guy with a pie

    I totally agree, all to many photographers rely on heavily editing thier photos. A master of photography relies on his judgment and light. This is what will allow the talented photographers to shine through. Not thoses who point, shoot, edit.

  • http://twitter.com/studiomayer/status/7878749995409408 Michael Mayer

    Poor Editing is Ruining Concert Photography: http://ow.ly/3e5bz

  • http://www.adjust3c.com Getty Image Office

    Poor editing really needs an enhancement to make images better and stunning to the eyes of the viewers.

  • http://twitter.com/ampedphotos/status/34784704024551424 Annie Wilson
  • http://twitter.com/ninjaloulou/status/34790638398472193 Lou Lou
  • http://twitter.com/adelheidephoto/status/34818163652694016 Heidi Takla
  • http://twitter.com/lschildermans/status/34966276984143872 Lode Schildermans

    A lesson for all of you out there: Poor Editing is Ruining Concert Photography http://bit.ly/bQoBx6

  • nedewe

    I certainly still have problems with chosing the bad from the good. Because I mostly have problems with choise. But I know it's my problem and I'm working on it. I'm being more critical about my own work and try to keep the best of the best. And if there are none? Then I'm sorry to say there are none left.

  • Olivier Cesar

    While agreeing with all (of almost) you said, I have to (still almost) disagree with one thing:
    -Why editing is more important thank shooting!

    Hmm.. If I take it straight, a really bad picture (like missing hand or a part of the mic or even better, I play guitar but you cannot see it.) can become a great picture? Not really agree!

    But on the other hand, I saw a lot of blurry pics with enough feelings in it to say that these are great pictures.

    But for the rest, I agree.. Better 5 good pics than 75 bad!

  • http://twitter.com/artistxposure Allen Ross Thomas

    Spot on Jacob. I agree 1000%.

    -A

  • http://twitter.com/artistxposure/status/35166541053956096 Allen Ross Thomas

    Great Article on Concert Photography and Editing: http://bit.ly/f9Ce2L

  • http://twitter.com/nrtdave/status/35296618131492864 dave_holzemer

    RT @artistxposure: Great Article on Concert Photography and Editing: http://bit.ly/f9Ce2L

Previous post:

Next post:

Advertisement